Can NaMo bring the change in India?
If people think a single person can change India they are fooling themselves.
BJP has just played a master stroke as it knows that most population don't try to reason out or go for logics. Making NaMo as PM candidate and hiding all other corrupt faces behind him. We, being innocent and very much attracted towards US, forget that US presidential election type campaign can be fruitful for party but equally harmful for public. India is a multi-party democratic country and party/alliance forms government but not an individual, PM can be changed anytime depending on majority vote of MPs of major alliance. Modi has kept his rally speech as NaMo vs RaGa and kept important issues aside.
Bharatiya Janata Party - Party based on "religious" beliefs or ideology. (Check this link)
Will Modi bring change- Yes, he will.
Will change be for good- Impossible!
How Wikileaks dammed the Narendra Modi wave | Latest News & Updates at Daily News & Analysis
WikiLeaks on its website, on Sunday, through its tweets, rubbished BJP's claims of quoting Modi as the 'lone honest Indian politician' and tweeted that it had only named a Congress leader Manoharsinh Jadeja in the diplomatic cable in 2011.
WikiLeaks had tweeted, 'No WikiLeaks document say Modi is 'incorruptible', rather he is popular because 'viewed' as 'incorruptible''.
Narendra Modi's speeches based on Youth and Change are inspired by Barack Obama, but now I guess he is out of ammunition and so started "sympathetic" appeal as speech in rallies. Same old scheme, lamenting Indian National Congress with dynasty rule and targeting Rahul Gandhi and now his self-inspirational story of "Tea-seller" and OBC.
Was he following Barack Obama in his initial phase of elevation as PM candidate just to gain public support and praise? I don't think Barack Obama ever brought his "colored-skin" as weapon to target his opposition and gain sympathy vote of public. Or is it that somehow he read our mind and got to know that we still have not changed, and so he can follow same old-rules of game!
A person who can't bring change in party itself can hardly bring any good changes in a country.
He may be better administrator than Manmohan Singh but it hardly proves that will be enough to bring positive changes which people are hoping for.
If I read his speeches, it is same old allegations which BJP has been putting on Congress since ages and people already know these things like dynasty rule and all that.
Let us not get emotional and go for facts.
Modi says he will bring Gujrat model in India.
1. Does he mean - In Gujarat, 57 MLAs face criminal charges - this particular Gujrat model will be used in India Parliament too.
Murder charges dog right-hand man of Narendra Modi
Hell, yes. I can see that. This is why he started his mission by bringing B S Yeddyurappa into BJP with open arms (SC refuses to stay trial against Yeddyurappa ). Nitin Gadkari is already in Core committee of BJP, forget about low profile BJP members with criminal charges.
Amit Shah like ministers are heading poll campaigns in UP. We can understand where we are heading into.
Tehelka exposé that nailed Amit Shah’s role in fake encounters | Tehelka Bureau | Tehelka.com
BJP, Congress spar over ‘Amit Shah snooping on woman for saheb’ case
Now you can imagine what type of BJP MPs are we going to see in Parliament (temple of Republic state) after LS election 2014.
2. Human Rights violation
Gujrat Riots 2002 : Demons in disguise of humans
Ishrat Jahan case
Human rights violation: Rise in cases against policemen with 205 in 2012 alone
Report of the Narmada International Human Rights Panel
Death of Soharbuddin Sheikh
Narendra Modi blamed for fake encounter killings policy in Gujarat - Telegraph
Narendra Modi's Gujarat model has no space for RTI activists
Gujarat: RTI activist Amit Jethwa shot dead
Eight RTI activists killed in seven months
Modi Is No Champion of India's Women
Shame: Woman activist protests, molested by policemen in Gujarat
I don't mean that all these are in hands of Narendra Modi, but same goes for Manmohan Singh too. What difference is proved and can be seen is in personality, one is aggressive in speech and other remains silent.
3. Scams
HC high cour order plugs Rs2,000 crore mining scam in Gujarat | Latest News & Updates at DNAIndia.com
Green tribunal rap for Hanjer over pollution at village in Gujarat
CAG blasts Narendra Modi govt for giving Rs 750 cr undue benefits to RIL, Essar
Gujarat PSUs gave undue benefits to business houses: CAG
CAG raps I-T for irregular tax exemption to 2 Tata trusts
No transparency.
Weak Lokpal law.
Supreme Court upholds Gujarat Lokayukta's appointmentGujarat Lokayukta Bill: Modi 'exposed' on claims of 'honest government', asserts senior advocate | Latest News & Updates at DNAIndia.com
4. Poor debt management - 8 holes CAG picked in Narendra Modi’s Gujarat development plan | The Economic Times
High income, yet high hunger levels in Gujarat
Poverty amid prosperity
Gujarat slums are one of the worst in India, say latest Census of India 2011 data and studies
Is Malnutrition In Gujarat Worse Than Sub Sahara? (-Justice Katju)
Gujarat behind national average in fall in maternal mortality rate | Latest News & Updates at DNAIndia.com
Health vulnerabilities in urban slum areas of Bhuj, Gujarat
Every third child in Gujarat is underweight, says CAG .com
In midst of word development and employment, we ignore health!
What drove 135 Gujarat farmers to suicide? | Latest News & Updates at DNAIndia.com
489 Gujarat farmers have committed suicide since 2003 (until 2007)
Gujarat to de-freeze agriculture land accounts of over 50 farmers
Narendra Modi’s turf flops on education, health - The Times of India
6. Growth rate -
The myth of Gujarat's exceptional GDP growth under Modi.
Gujarat vs Bihar: which development model works best?
Bihar tops country in GDP growth rate at 13.1% (Note- Nitish Kumar had to start from -ve, then come to scratch and has now made a good positive changes!)
7. If "Vibrant Gujrat" has real buzz -
Corporate Cronyism in ‘Vibrant Gujarat’
How vibrant is the Gujarat growth story?
The vibrant Gujarat myth
Gujarati women’s plight in a so-called ‘Vibrant Gujarat’ | Latest News & Updates at DNAIndia.com
‘Not a ‘vibrant’ Gujarat on women’s issues’
https://twitter.com/meerasanyal/statuses/182025017167589376
This tweet is by Meera Sanyal during her 2012 visit to Gujrat and was not even member of AAP then.
There have been developmental works in Gujrat, which is great and learning for other states too. But we should try to find out who should be credited for particular development works. It is always State Govt. who fly away with full credits even if it has zero or partial role to play in it. Since article is getting long, I will give an example : Solar and Winder power projects in Gujrat are not solely of State Govt. but initiative of Central Govt. schemes (national planning) - Central and State Government Solar Policies - EAI.in, After Rajasthan, Centre plans solar, wind power projects in Gujarat, Solar power in India
Instance of Education sector (Govt.) and Mafia :
We also need to see the potentiality of Gujrat and how is government utilizing on potential resources. Not many states are lucky with several natural resources like petroleum, coal, sea-beach (ports), river etc. Developmental plans and budget depends on demographic and geographic conditions too.
It is very illogical and foolish to believe that Gujrat growth model (myth or fact) can work at national level.
Are there Naxalite problem in Gujrat, which are there in some other states of India? Do people in other states undermine education and give more priority to business than education? Do people in other states are in traditional practice of business, or have capitals, atmosphere etc.
8. Won't extremist groups and parties like Shiv Shena start there goonism all over again with more support from government?
List can go on and on.
(Do watch this video and listen comments by Gujrat's public)
Gujrat is developed. Has some good plans. But can we ignore all other important facts?
Okay, some argument will be, I don't give damn about poors, others. My family is safe and probability that I or my family will fall under violation of Human right by govt. is highly unlikely (impossible). I'm educated and don't bother if education and research is not primary concern.
He has been ruling in Gujrat for three consecutive terms and see the difference.
The promises which he is making now, can they be fulfilled in just 5 years? India is a country and not a state (reminder!).
Next important issue, do you think BJP (NDA) can get 271+ seats?
What if not? Then like Delhi assembly election, will it go for re-election or ask second major party to form government and play role of opposition? Or will it form alliance with other parties? If it forms alliance with other parties, can it take stand against ministers of allied parties if they are found in scams or some ongoing cases? Who will be PM if supporting parties don't like NaMo? Has these important issues been discussed by BJP because then announcing of NaMo as PM candidate does not make any sense!
Doublespeak on corruption!
The below part forms my opinion -
Here are some interview and questionnaire sessions with Yogendra Yadav and Arvind Kejriwal that may help you think if there exists an alternative -
I'm very much sure these will clear most of your doubts, misconception, biases or lack of information.
Do you wish only Delhites to have all the fun of Mohalla Politics and The AAP or wish to participate/watch by yourself as audience too!!
A gentleman who attracts criticism because he walks the talk - it happens only in Me(In)dia.
Declares to resign if Jan Lokpal is not passed -
(Discussion on AAP model of governance and development policies)
After resignation -
On 'tactical' move of ArKe and AAP (resignation from Cabinet) -
Discussion with Industrialists at CII, 17 Feb 2014 -
Copying speech from US is easy to mislead people (particularly youth category), but a real "thinker" and administrator has vision and ideas (realistic and some have been put on trial too) -
Rahul Gandhi : He uses phrases and words like Open system, Women Empowerment, Youth, RTI etc. but can't form a proper meaningful sentence.
Narendra Modi : Forms artful sentence with words like 5Ts- Trade, Technology, Tourism, etc. People get fascinated after hearings such terms and a meaningful sentence. (But if sentence can be realistic or not, and what is mechanism, no one gives second thought!)
Arvind Kejriwal : Gives model of Governance - Corruption-free system, security, infrastructure, policies. Plain and simple. (People think his vocabulary is not as good as Modi)
The Youth of our country should become job-givers rather than job-takers. -Arvind Kejriwal
Swaraj (Democracy) policy of AAP -
AAP is in the situation of The miller, his son and the donkey. We Indians live in a society which will have entities who can come up with some or the other biased reasons and criticize any move, like most of the time media does.
We have been choosing among the worse, but this is the first time we can choose for good!
We had only option of B or C but now we have A.
Decide yourself!
Arnab Goswami's interviewing Kejriwal before election -
First addressal of Assembly by CM Kejriwal -
__________________________________________________________
On your own risk,
For some more claims and statistics :http://indianexponent.com/why-the-so-called-achievements-of-narendra-modi-in-gujarat-dont-impress-me/
some links which put Gujrati's view on Gujrat Model -Page on pheku.in, Reasons For Not Voting Modi . Facts and Lies
I've come to know a fact that Gujrat Govt. knowingly distorts the fact regarding oppression and death of farmers and poors in Gujrat. There are some agencies who cheat underprivileged ones during surveys or for profit-motive. I currently don't have statistics, hence it is upon you to ignore or try finding the truth. I've come to know this through my friend at ICTS, Banglore. Some faculties in this institute are also working as social activists for related cause.
If people think a single person can change India they are fooling themselves.
BJP has just played a master stroke as it knows that most population don't try to reason out or go for logics. Making NaMo as PM candidate and hiding all other corrupt faces behind him. We, being innocent and very much attracted towards US, forget that US presidential election type campaign can be fruitful for party but equally harmful for public. India is a multi-party democratic country and party/alliance forms government but not an individual, PM can be changed anytime depending on majority vote of MPs of major alliance. Modi has kept his rally speech as NaMo vs RaGa and kept important issues aside.
Bharatiya Janata Party - Party based on "religious" beliefs or ideology. (Check this link)
Will Modi bring change- Yes, he will.
Will change be for good- Impossible!
WikiLeaks had tweeted, 'No WikiLeaks document say Modi is 'incorruptible', rather he is popular because 'viewed' as 'incorruptible''.
A failed Government can't run for a full term, if it is able to do so, then it implies Opposition didn't play its role and failed too.
UPA was successful in 2004-2009 and BJP was miserable then opposing Nuclear Deal -BJP opposes Indo-US nuclear deal - Hindustan Times
UPA won superbly and started its second term.
Narendra Modi's speeches based on Youth and Change are inspired by Barack Obama, but now I guess he is out of ammunition and so started "sympathetic" appeal as speech in rallies. Same old scheme, lamenting Indian National Congress with dynasty rule and targeting Rahul Gandhi and now his self-inspirational story of "Tea-seller" and OBC.
Was he following Barack Obama in his initial phase of elevation as PM candidate just to gain public support and praise? I don't think Barack Obama ever brought his "colored-skin" as weapon to target his opposition and gain sympathy vote of public. Or is it that somehow he read our mind and got to know that we still have not changed, and so he can follow same old-rules of game!
ArKe kaash kuch nahi karta! - For some detail discussion of AAP governance during Jan.
A person who can't bring change in party itself can hardly bring any good changes in a country.
He may be better administrator than Manmohan Singh but it hardly proves that will be enough to bring positive changes which people are hoping for.
If I read his speeches, it is same old allegations which BJP has been putting on Congress since ages and people already know these things like dynasty rule and all that.
Let us not get emotional and go for facts.
Modi says he will bring Gujrat model in India.
1. Does he mean - In Gujarat, 57 MLAs face criminal charges - this particular Gujrat model will be used in India Parliament too.
Murder charges dog right-hand man of Narendra Modi
Hell, yes. I can see that. This is why he started his mission by bringing B S Yeddyurappa into BJP with open arms (SC refuses to stay trial against Yeddyurappa ). Nitin Gadkari is already in Core committee of BJP, forget about low profile BJP members with criminal charges.
Amit Shah like ministers are heading poll campaigns in UP. We can understand where we are heading into.
Tehelka exposé that nailed Amit Shah’s role in fake encounters | Tehelka Bureau | Tehelka.com
BJP, Congress spar over ‘Amit Shah snooping on woman for saheb’ case
Now you can imagine what type of BJP MPs are we going to see in Parliament (temple of Republic state) after LS election 2014.
2. Human Rights violation
Gujrat Riots 2002 : Demons in disguise of humans
Ishrat Jahan case
Human rights violation: Rise in cases against policemen with 205 in 2012 alone
Report of the Narmada International Human Rights Panel
Death of Soharbuddin Sheikh
Narendra Modi blamed for fake encounter killings policy in Gujarat - Telegraph
Narendra Modi's Gujarat model has no space for RTI activists
Gujarat: RTI activist Amit Jethwa shot dead
Eight RTI activists killed in seven months
Modi Is No Champion of India's Women
Shame: Woman activist protests, molested by policemen in Gujarat
I don't mean that all these are in hands of Narendra Modi, but same goes for Manmohan Singh too. What difference is proved and can be seen is in personality, one is aggressive in speech and other remains silent.
3. Scams
HC high cour order plugs Rs2,000 crore mining scam in Gujarat | Latest News & Updates at DNAIndia.com
Green tribunal rap for Hanjer over pollution at village in Gujarat
CAG blasts Narendra Modi govt for giving Rs 750 cr undue benefits to RIL, Essar
Gujarat PSUs gave undue benefits to business houses: CAG
CAG raps I-T for irregular tax exemption to 2 Tata trusts
No transparency.
Weak Lokpal law.
Supreme Court upholds Gujarat Lokayukta's appointmentGujarat Lokayukta Bill: Modi 'exposed' on claims of 'honest government', asserts senior advocate | Latest News & Updates at DNAIndia.com
4. Poor debt management - 8 holes CAG picked in Narendra Modi’s Gujarat development plan | The Economic Times
High income, yet high hunger levels in Gujarat
Poverty amid prosperity
Gujarat slums are one of the worst in India, say latest Census of India 2011 data and studies
Is Malnutrition In Gujarat Worse Than Sub Sahara? (-Justice Katju)
Gujarat behind national average in fall in maternal mortality rate | Latest News & Updates at DNAIndia.com
Health vulnerabilities in urban slum areas of Bhuj, Gujarat
Every third child in Gujarat is underweight, says CAG .com
In midst of word development and employment, we ignore health!
What drove 135 Gujarat farmers to suicide? | Latest News & Updates at DNAIndia.com
489 Gujarat farmers have committed suicide since 2003 (until 2007)
Gujarat to de-freeze agriculture land accounts of over 50 farmers
Narendra Modi’s turf flops on education, health - The Times of India
6. Growth rate -
The myth of Gujarat's exceptional GDP growth under Modi.
Gujarat vs Bihar: which development model works best?
Bihar tops country in GDP growth rate at 13.1% (Note- Nitish Kumar had to start from -ve, then come to scratch and has now made a good positive changes!)
7. If "Vibrant Gujrat" has real buzz -
Corporate Cronyism in ‘Vibrant Gujarat’
How vibrant is the Gujarat growth story?
The vibrant Gujarat myth
Gujarati women’s plight in a so-called ‘Vibrant Gujarat’ | Latest News & Updates at DNAIndia.com
‘Not a ‘vibrant’ Gujarat on women’s issues’
https://twitter.com/meerasanyal/statuses/182025017167589376
This tweet is by Meera Sanyal during her 2012 visit to Gujrat and was not even member of AAP then.
There have been developmental works in Gujrat, which is great and learning for other states too. But we should try to find out who should be credited for particular development works. It is always State Govt. who fly away with full credits even if it has zero or partial role to play in it. Since article is getting long, I will give an example : Solar and Winder power projects in Gujrat are not solely of State Govt. but initiative of Central Govt. schemes (national planning) - Central and State Government Solar Policies - EAI.in, After Rajasthan, Centre plans solar, wind power projects in Gujarat, Solar power in India
Instance of Education sector (Govt.) and Mafia :
We also need to see the potentiality of Gujrat and how is government utilizing on potential resources. Not many states are lucky with several natural resources like petroleum, coal, sea-beach (ports), river etc. Developmental plans and budget depends on demographic and geographic conditions too.
It is very illogical and foolish to believe that Gujrat growth model (myth or fact) can work at national level.
Are there Naxalite problem in Gujrat, which are there in some other states of India? Do people in other states undermine education and give more priority to business than education? Do people in other states are in traditional practice of business, or have capitals, atmosphere etc.
8. Won't extremist groups and parties like Shiv Shena start there goonism all over again with more support from government?
List can go on and on.
Gujrat is developed. Has some good plans. But can we ignore all other important facts?
Okay, some argument will be, I don't give damn about poors, others. My family is safe and probability that I or my family will fall under violation of Human right by govt. is highly unlikely (impossible). I'm educated and don't bother if education and research is not primary concern.
He has been ruling in Gujrat for three consecutive terms and see the difference.
The promises which he is making now, can they be fulfilled in just 5 years? India is a country and not a state (reminder!).
Next important issue, do you think BJP (NDA) can get 271+ seats?
What if not? Then like Delhi assembly election, will it go for re-election or ask second major party to form government and play role of opposition? Or will it form alliance with other parties? If it forms alliance with other parties, can it take stand against ministers of allied parties if they are found in scams or some ongoing cases? Who will be PM if supporting parties don't like NaMo? Has these important issues been discussed by BJP because then announcing of NaMo as PM candidate does not make any sense!
Doublespeak on corruption!
The below part forms my opinion -
Those who have faith in themselves, those who have dare to challenge backward traditional practices, don't bother about "Char Log", have heart of an entrepreneur, guts to back yourself and rise again when you fall, ready to explore to defy all odds - will certainly find the alternate solution to the situation and problem. I request you to propagate your opinion and thinking to others, if you think it is for good. Take decision that is the best for you and in your constituency. :)
Here are some interview and questionnaire sessions with Yogendra Yadav and Arvind Kejriwal that may help you think if there exists an alternative -
I'm very much sure these will clear most of your doubts, misconception, biases or lack of information.
- APP is for transparent and clean Government.
- AAP is neither left nor right.
- AAP is neither socialist nor capitalist.
- AAP is against unconstitutional practices -Anti-corruption, Khaps etc.
Do you wish only Delhites to have all the fun of Mohalla Politics and The AAP or wish to participate/watch by yourself as audience too!!
A gentleman who attracts criticism because he walks the talk - it happens only in Me(In)dia.
Declares to resign if Jan Lokpal is not passed -
After resignation -
On 'tactical' move of ArKe and AAP (resignation from Cabinet) -
Discussion with Industrialists at CII, 17 Feb 2014 -
Copying speech from US is easy to mislead people (particularly youth category), but a real "thinker" and administrator has vision and ideas (realistic and some have been put on trial too) -
Rahul Gandhi : He uses phrases and words like Open system, Women Empowerment, Youth, RTI etc. but can't form a proper meaningful sentence.
Narendra Modi : Forms artful sentence with words like 5Ts- Trade, Technology, Tourism, etc. People get fascinated after hearings such terms and a meaningful sentence. (But if sentence can be realistic or not, and what is mechanism, no one gives second thought!)
Arvind Kejriwal : Gives model of Governance - Corruption-free system, security, infrastructure, policies. Plain and simple. (People think his vocabulary is not as good as Modi)
The Youth of our country should become job-givers rather than job-takers. -Arvind Kejriwal
Swaraj (Democracy) policy of AAP -
AAP is in the situation of The miller, his son and the donkey. We Indians live in a society which will have entities who can come up with some or the other biased reasons and criticize any move, like most of the time media does.
AAP has become voice of Indian public (if not all, then most or some) and is in sync with their feelings.
Go through the core-committee members of AAP, its election candidates and then question if they are the ones whom you would like to represent public in Parliament and Assembly.
We have been choosing among the worse, but this is the first time we can choose for good!
We had only option of B or C but now we have A.
Decide yourself!
Arnab Goswami's interviewing Kejriwal before election -
First addressal of Assembly by CM Kejriwal -
On your own risk,
For some more claims and statistics :http://indianexponent.com/why-the-so-called-achievements-of-narendra-modi-in-gujarat-dont-impress-me/
some links which put Gujrati's view on Gujrat Model -Page on pheku.in, Reasons For Not Voting Modi . Facts and Lies
I've come to know a fact that Gujrat Govt. knowingly distorts the fact regarding oppression and death of farmers and poors in Gujrat. There are some agencies who cheat underprivileged ones during surveys or for profit-motive. I currently don't have statistics, hence it is upon you to ignore or try finding the truth. I've come to know this through my friend at ICTS, Banglore. Some faculties in this institute are also working as social activists for related cause.
No comments:
Post a Comment